When it’s time for a new roof, the material you choose shapes everything that follows — how your home looks, how long the roof lasts, how much it costs, and how well it holds up to Illinois weather. There’s no single “best” option, only the best fit for your home, your budget, and your goals. Here’s an honest comparison of the most popular choices.
Asphalt shingles — the dependable all-rounder
Asphalt is far and away the most common residential roofing material, and for good reason. It’s affordable, comes in a wide range of colors and styles, and performs reliably through Midwest seasons. Expect roughly 20–25 years of life, with premium architectural shingles lasting longer and adding curb appeal. For most Chicagoland homeowners, asphalt delivers the best balance of cost and performance.
Cedar shake — natural character and warmth
Cedar shake roofing brings a distinctive, upscale look that ages beautifully. It offers decent insulation and a timeless, natural aesthetic. In exchange, cedar asks for more maintenance to protect against moisture and the elements, and it sits at a higher price point than asphalt. It’s a wonderful choice for homeowners who want charm and are willing to care for it.
Slate & tile — the century roof
Natural slate and ceramic tile are the premium end of the market. They’re stunning, exceptionally durable, and can last generations — often 75–100 years or more. The trade-offs are cost and weight: these materials are heavy and require a home structure that can support them, plus specialized installation. For the right property, though, few materials rival their beauty and longevity. Modern synthetic alternatives like DaVinci offer a similar look at reduced weight.
Metal — modern, tough, and efficient
Metal roofing has surged in popularity, and it earns the attention. It’s remarkably durable (often 40–70 years), sheds snow and rain easily, resists fire, and reflects heat to help with energy efficiency. It costs more upfront than asphalt but can be a smart long-term investment, especially for homeowners planning to stay put.
Commercial buildings: TPO & modified bitumen
For flat and low-slope commercial roofs, single-ply TPO and modified bitumen systems are the workhorses — engineered for durability, weather resistance, and energy efficiency on larger structures.
How to choose the right one
The right material comes down to a handful of questions: What’s your budget, up front and over time? How long do you plan to stay in the home? What look are you after, and what does your home’s structure support? A good roofing contractor helps you weigh those factors honestly rather than steering you toward the most expensive option.
At Royalty Roofing & Siding, we install everything from asphalt and cedar shake to slate, tile, DaVinci, and metal — plus commercial TPO and modified bitumen. We’ll walk your home with you, explain the real trade-offs, and recommend what genuinely fits. That’s what “quality over quantity” means to us.
Ready to explore your options? Get a free consultation and competitive estimate — call (630) 880-2877.
